Across the healthcare landscape, change is in the air. It’s what we’re living in and surrounded by at all times. We’re good at dealing with it, or putting up with it, as the case may be. But how do you control it? There’s no single answer. And because each healthcare organization is different, each challenge is unique. However, a good starting place is Lewin’s Change Theory.
Kurt Lewin is one of the founders of modern social psychology, though the roots of his theory are ancient. Yet, it stands the test of time, and its framework provides a solid foundation for sterile processing departments (SPDs) to build on.
Change is often necessary in sterile processing departments because they are linchpins in the perioperative process. However, this also makes change difficult, as each adjustment has ramifications for the broader perioperative department. In this article, Sullivan Healthcare Consulting’s team of sterile processing department consultants will explain Lewin’s Change Theory and showcase how it can be applied to help solve the challenges facing sterile processing departments.
Unfreeze Stage
This initial phase involves creating awareness of the need for change by identifying problems with the current situation and making people uncomfortable with the status quo.
Open Communications
By the time Lewin’s Change Theory is implemented, certain groups will be aware of the problems facing a hospital or ASC. However, not all groups will share that knowledge. For example, in a recent Sullivan engagement, surgeons, particularly neurosurgeons, were painfully aware of the SPD’s problems and were fed up with it.
Successfully unfreezing things demands that the problems be widely understood, so communication channels must exist to get everyone on the same page. In many cases, this is a significant step forward in itself. Countless organizations that SHC has worked with have had adversarial relationships between OR teams and sterile processing teams. While the frustration experienced in the OR is entirely understandable and valid, the typical relationship doesn’t earn support from SPD teams, who are often under enormous strain and without critical resources.
Establishing a surgical executive committee and engaging stakeholders from the OR, SPD, anesthesia, and scheduling can create an environment where feedback is clear, and teams can work together to pursue a unified goal.
Get Help
Unfreezing seems like the easiest part of Lewin’s Change Theory—and it can be. But getting it right is decidedly tricky. After all, SPDs and hospitals struggle to identify their problems for many of the same reasons those problems exist in the first place: because it’s always been done that way.
One of the most effective ways to successfully unfreeze is by bringing fresh eyes to the situation, often in the form of an expert consultant. Sterile processing consultants bring two things in addition to the specialized expertise needed for departments in crisis:
- A new, wider perspective with systems thinking
- The experience of what works and what doesn’t in hundreds of other SPDs across the country
A consultant can help your organization identify the root causes plaguing your SPD and prevent your organization from barking up the wrong trees. And do consultants cost a pretty penny? They sure do. But the investment is considerably less than the cost of doing nothing, and even less than implementing the wrong solutions.
State The Precise Problems
With or without a consultant, identifying problems in SPD is often a work in measurement. So, get out your stopwatches, clipboards, and calculators and get started.
- How long does it take to wash an instrument?
- How long does it take to wash a tray of instruments?
- What’s your tray defect rate?
- What’s your rewash rate?
- What’s your IUSS rate?
With these measurements, your SPD can reliably compare to industry quality, speed, and safety benchmarks.
Get Uncomfortable
Guided by the results of your measurements, it’s time for your organization and SPD to start asking questions and drawing conclusions. After identifying and measuring results, the questions your SPD will be asking will have answers that make you uncomfortable. That’s okay. In fact, that’s the point of the unfreeze stage of Lewin’s Change Theory. Because here’s the thing: something’s wrong. Whether that’s your workflow, quality metrics, or staffing ratios, it’s impacting your department’s organizational culture, your organization’s bottom line, and above all, your patients’ safety.
The last step of the unfreeze stage of Lewin’s Change Theory is to get uncomfortable, and, unlike every other piece of advice, this is not something you should be comfortable with. Indeed, the last thing your organization should do before moving on to the change stage is to build a consensus that the status quo’s results are profoundly discomfiting and unacceptable. Only when everyone from the OR to the SPD agrees that change is necessary can you successfully implement change, so you should only move forward when you can assure your changes will take root.
Change Stage
The change stage is the most engaging, difficult, and exciting phase. As you implement new behaviors, processes, and systems, you’ll hit roadblocks, discover how hard it is to break bad habits and uncover additional challenges. However, during the change stage, you’ll also start seeing results that confirm what you’ve known all along: that your SPD can positively impact the organization’s success.
With that in mind, let’s dive deeper into key areas your change will likely focus on.
Implementing New Processes
Staffing is a leading concern for sterile processing directors, so maximizing staff efficiency should be a critical area of focus. This means that labor should be divided strategically among staff to minimize redundancy and wasted time. SPD technicians should each become the leader for certain tasks. This can cultivate a sense of ownership accompanied by higher standards and reduce the time technicians spend going from a cart to a sink, a washer to a rack, and so forth.
Further, an SPD might be struggling because it’s not using the resources available to it. Instrument tracking is commonplace in SPDs, yet many department directors haven’t fully implemented one. Keeping track of each instrument’s history and creating a clear chain of custody for each item as it passes through the SPD enhances accountability, reduces losses and waste, and reduces the time it takes to identify and replace equipment that’s reached the end of its life.
Develop Long-Term Communications Channels
During the unfreeze stage, high-level communications between sterile processing directors and OR directors are established to build consensus on what’s going on and what needs fixing. During the change stage, those communications are formalized and turned into recurring meetings, and additionally, communications channels are opened for day-to-day operations.
This can be as simple as moving from emails—which can slip through the cracks and descend into incivility—to phone calls, which are more immediate and require a greater level of respect and civility. Or, it can be a change in how instruments are delivered to ORs, and adopting a customer-first perspective in the SPD, with technicians seeking to provide the greatest level of service to ORs.
Continue Staff Education
Depending on the history of a sterile processing department, it’s entirely possible that technicians aren’t meeting standards simply because they weren’t trained to meet them. Developing a continuing education program can reinforce the necessary quality criteria and address the deficiencies you found during your unfreeze stage.
Get Coached Through Change
As noted in the unfreeze stage, change is only effective when it changes in the right direction. Without proper guidance, even the best-intentioned SPDs can see their change stage derail and move in a direction that doesn’t create lasting change.
This is another area where a consultant can provide priceless oversight. By tapping into their experiences with hundreds of other departments, they can quickly identify when the work being done stops serving the needs identified during the unfreeze stage. Sullivan’s consultants are uniquely capable in this regard, as they’ll provide hands-on implementation support rather than just coaching from their office. This further enhances accountability and generates the critical mass of buy-in needed to cultivate lasting change.
Refreeze Stage
Applications of Lewin’s Change Theory are completed by refreezing the changes, effectively normalizing new processes and behaviors. Refreezing’s difficulty depends on how thorough, realistic, and sustainable the processes introduced in the change stage are.
Dramatic changes that lack the needed infrastructure will struggle to be frozen in place, while those that are attainable and easily replicable will take hold like a duck takes to water. That’s not to say that complex changes can’t be made using Lewin’s Change Theory, but that any change needs to be supported by the right processes and resources.
Here, we’ll take a look at how changes can be supported with positive reinforcement and policy adjustments,
Carry Out Regular Quality Audits
Accountability is paramount to the success of a sterile processing department. Implementing instrument tracking programs during the change phase can help improve staff accountability, but one of the best tools for holding the department to a high standard is through quality audits. By regularly assessing the output of your SPD in terms of quality and safety and comparing that to industry benchmarks, you can be confident that you’re making continuous improvements and that the changes you’ve made have been frozen in place.
Create Long-Term Career Paths
If staffing is a challenge in your SPD, creating long-term career paths can be helpful for refreezing change. When sterile processing techs have a clear career path, it incentivizes them to help refreeze things and continue improving them. However, when there’s no clear way for techs to progress their careers, they risk becoming disengaged and less invested in maintaining the changes you’ve made.
Remember Life Before Unfreezing
One benefit of reinventing your sterile processing department with Lewin’s Change Theory is how it clearly distinguishes time periods. This makes it easy to recall the time before unfreezing, which in itself can be a great motivator to continue freezing and maintaining changes.
Remember, nobody likes chaos or working in an unpredictable, high-stress environment. While the nature of SPD makes it nearly impossible to eliminate it entirely—washers will go down, staff will be sick, etc.—an effectively frozen change will make sterile processing more peaceful and predictable.
Is It Time For a Change? Contact Sullivan Healthcare Consulting
Lewin’s Change Theory is a great model for managing change in sterile processing departments. SPDs play a vital role in an OR department’s success, yet they’re often the subject of much ire and yet the recipients of little attention or resources. Lewin’s Change Theory helps break down the barriers that disconnect SPDs from the OR department, identify the issues that hold them back, and create lasting changes to mend relationships and improve efficiency, quality, and patient safety.
If your SPD is facing challenges, you’re far from alone, and fortunately, you don’t have to accept the status quo. Sullivan Healthcare Consulting’s team has decades of experience in all of perioperative care, and we’re home to some of the country’s leading SPD consultants. To discuss what’s holding your department back, schedule a free 30-minute consultation with Bill Bailey, Sullivan’s senior sterile processing consultant. To schedule your free call, get in touch with Karen Cooley today.