To ASC Or Not to ASC: Integrated Care in ASCs

by | Aug 20, 2026

The story of the ASC market is the story of site-of-care shifts and case migrations. That migration is nearly complete, and the ASC market is very mature at this point. It has expanded to handle nearly all the cases it can safely and feasibly handle. In orthopedics, for example, roughly 70% of procedures that can be safely completed in the outpatient setting have already migrated. 

Take total joint replacements, for example. Total knee, hip, and shoulder arthroplasty procedures (TKA, THA, and TSA, respectively) were overwhelmingly completed in the hospital environment as late as 2018. At that time, total knee arthroplasty operations were performed in the outpatient environment just 28% of the time, and less than 10% of the time for both TSA and THA. Fast forward to 2024, and all three were performed in the outpatient setting approximately 75% of the time or more.

By 2028, 85% of procedures will be safely completed in ASCs or HOPDs. That reflects nearly all procedures falling outside the domains of infectious diseases, neuroscience, and obstetrics.

Multiple Business Models in The Modern ASC Environment

While the outpatient and ASC environment has matured and become increasingly competitive, it has also opened up new business models. Surgeons who were early adopters of the ASC model often had little choice but to go at it alone (and with partners). The emergence of ASC management groups introduced flexibility, but also reduced physicians’ control over their facilities. Today, surgeon investors aren’t trapped in that dichotomy; there’s much more flexibility in how ASCs are arranged:

  • Standalone ASCs
  • Joint-venture facilities
  • System-aligned ASCs

This is a direct result of the case migration of higher-acuity cases, for which there’s an increasing demand. And, to meet that demand, health systems across the country are seeking to partner with surgeons to grow their outpatient capacity.

For surgeons, this means being able to choose the balance of autonomy, capital, and operational support they want, wherever they are in their career. That said, we need to reiterate that the ASC market has, by and large, matured. It’s no longer an ‘early adopter’ play; rather, for most health systems and hospitals, ASCs are core to overall orthopedic strategies. So, regardless of how an ASC’s ownership is arranged, it’s increasingly vital to have a business plan that stands out and allows your facility to compete.

What’s Next? Shifting From ASC-Only to a Care Continuum

How can you differentiate your ASC? How can you stand out? It’s increasingly challenging for ASCs. Viewed on an innovation adoption curve, the shift to ASCs has thoroughly reached the point where only ‘laggards’ haven’t made the change. Even so, there’s always another adoption curve just over the horizon.

Today, the leading differentiator we’re seeing ASCs find success with is integrating more and more elements throughout the entire care continuum, thus providing a superior, smoother patient experience. These facilities become a patient’s one-stop shop, not just for ASC services like orthopedics, but also for the pre- and post-operative services they’ll need like imaging, physical therapy, and pharmaceuticals. Some facilities are even integrating a clinic or urgent care to meet community needs and drive referrals.

The Care Continuum In Action: St. Luke’s Center for Orthopedics & Sports Medicine

Sullivan Healthcare Consulting was engaged to help bring St. Luke’s Center for Orthopedics & Sports Medicine (COSM) to life in Boise, ID. The scale of the project was truly immense. Let’s break it down.

In its 230,000² ft facility, St. Luke’s COSM features:

  • An on-site pharmacy, with retail products available to the public
  • A comprehensive imaging suite, featuring the region’s only weight-bearing CT scanner, alongside a host of other traditional imaging services
  • 12 operating rooms surrounding a sterile core
  • 45 pre- and post-operative recovery rooms
  • 10-bed extended recovery unit on third floor; building is licensed as part of the hospital’s outpatient department and can provide care for up to 24 hours.
  • Orthopedic Walk-In Care
  • Indoor/Outdoor rehabilitation gym
  • An entire administrative suite

St. Luke’s has been open for two years now. They first opened their ambulatory clinics, imaging, and rehabilitation clinics in February, 2024. By April, they were ready to open their surgery center and pharmacy, starting with four ORs. They expanded to six ORs by September 2025, and eight by July 2026. This staggered opening was driven by a desire not just to open quickly, but to open well.

How An Integrated Care Continuum Breaks Down By The Numbers

With an outlay of $195 million, the facility was facing great expectations. So far, it’s meeting them. In its first full year of operations, St. Luke’s COSM had monthly averages of the following:

Clinic Visits: 8,500

Orthopedic Urgent Care Visits: 825

Medical Imaging Procedures: 2,900

Physical Therapy Procedures: 4,800

Occupational Therapy Procedures: 700

Surgeries: 440

Injections: 120

Altogether, that adds up to roughly 700-750 patients on campus at any given time, not to mention their families and friends there to support and guide them.

Those patients were in the care of a competent, well-organized team of 21 employed physicians, 14 employed APPs, 320 FTE staff, 32 surgeons, and 5 PM&R (roughly half of these surgeons are independent).

Now, those are impressive numbers, but the context you care about is patient experience and the bottom line. So, how is St. Luke’s stacking up in those regards? Financially, things couldn’t be better; the system is on track to recoup its $195 million investment not just within the anticipated 15.5 years, but as early as 10 years.

Patient-Centered Success

And in terms of patient experience, it’s also exceeding expectations. St. Luke’s COSM is unique because it takes a novel approach to the patient experience, and that is at the core of the integrated care model. It’s easy to throw around words like ‘streamline’ from both the business and healthcare perspective, yet that’s truly what the COSM project was focused on: streamlining the patient care experience. That’s their key differentiator in a competitive local market.

Two years in, the results have been promising, with patients overwhelmingly noting how easy it is to navigate the services at St. Luke’s. Now, think: when’s the last time you’ve heard a patient use the word ‘easy’ to describe what it was like to get care?

Key Points To Focus On As You Expand Care Offerings

Let’s be candid: you probably aren’t going to build a 230,000² ft integrated care facility. However, that doesn’t mean the model St. Luke’s followed for its COSM isn’t relevant to you, your ASC, or your health system. We’ve been working in the ASC space for decades now. We were there as it emerged. We watched it grow and mature. Today, we’re guiding it to a new frontier that’s more cohesive for everyone.

Care is a continuum, and facilities that integrate the points along that continuum into a single experience, like St. Luke’s, will play an increasingly important role in how care is delivered regardless of square footage. If you’re ready to bring your ASC to the next level, here are some key elements to focus on.

1. Detailed Market Research

To provide an elite patient experience that differentiates your facility, your ASC market research needs to be exceedingly thorough. Fundamentally, the content of the analysis expands when you pursue an integrated care experience, because you’re not simply looking for gaps in the market. You are also assessing the sticking points and friction patients experience, and how integrating services under one roof can alleviate them.

2. Effective Staffing and Leadership

Naturally, staffing your ASC for success is vital. Leadership is equally important. From governance structures to day-to-day operations, you want the right people in place.

“A successful ASC really needs to be physician-driven,” said Robert Eisenberg, MBA, RN, CASC, Senior Vice President and ASC Practice Leader at Sullivan Healthcare Consulting. “That doesn’t mean you need to do all the work, but it does mean that you need to be integrated into the decision-making; you need to be the leader. Our most successful surgery centers are the ones that have very strong physician governance.”

3. Compliance And Regulatory Readiness

As your ASC taps into the expanded care continuum, opportunities increase substantially. However, that increased opportunity also brings greater risk exposure. As service lines are added, your ASC must continually assess regulations to stay in compliance and continue delivering an exceptional patient experience.

ASC — Or Be Left Behind

The question of ‘to ASC or not to ASC’ has long been answered. However, as the ASC market approaches a new crossroads, the facilities that pursue integrations across the care continuum will lead the way forward. And those that don’t? Well, they may be left behind.

The future of ASCs is one where the disparate, multi-site care continuum is increasingly integrated under one roof, providing a streamlined patient experience and opening new opportunities for surgeons.

Facilities that can combine an integrated care experience with detailed market research, excellent leadership and staffing, and rigorous compliance will be prepared to smoothly introduce new offerings that set them apart from the competition, benefiting their patients and their bottom line.

If you’re ready to explore which care integrations make the most sense for your market and facility, follow St. Luke’s lead and get in touch with Sullivan Healthcare Consulting. Whether you’re pursuing a facility with two, four, or 14 ORs, you can rest assured we’ll bring the same degree of expertise to your project.

Why Sullivan Healthcare Consulting

St. Luke’s COSM project was a massive investment — an investment at a scale that was too big to fail — as in, cannot afford to fail. They turned to Sullivan because they wanted a partner with proven end-to-end experience.

“Sullivan was there with us every step of the way, guiding us, informing us on everything from design to workflows to staffing models,” said Nicole M. Brown, MBA, CMPE, COO of Orthopedics & Sports Medicine, St. Luke’s. “We needed a very visible partner, and we had all the right people on the ground working with our people. It really felt like a partnership; it was not a transactional relationship.”

What more can we say? Contact our team today to discuss your project.

Let’s Connect Today